It struck me as I’m trying to plan my essay that more traditional taxonomic information architecures are something of a metaphor for representative democracies around the world. Taxonomic architectures offer a more regimented website structure and navigation – a website’s author surely trying to create something he/she feels will be of use to the site’s target audience, whilst this can be effective it’s not a true representation of what the audience want (well, it may not be, there’s no easy way to know with this structure which is the point). So, we figured that our online democracies could be made easier to navigate and more effective by allowing the users to collaboratively author their own information architectures.
As IMPs we are probably striving to produce/design things that are folksonomies, have tagging, give more user control, and something that over time becomes more representative of what the sites’ users want. All good.
Now think about democracy in our country. We vote for who we think can best represent our own beliefs to make decisions on our behalf. That’s alot of responsibility for a handful of people to have, and when you consider that a vote is basically a glorified popularity contest you might begin to think that maybe the people you vote might not have your best interests at mind. Were loads and loads of people attempting to participate in democracy to show they don’t approve of our England’s support of Bush’ illegal war in Iraq? Yes. Were they listened to? No. Obviously the amount of protesters isn’t the majority of voters but imagine if we were asked in a referendum or something, then more of a true figure of people against it would emerge. Since then it has emerged that some top guy in the American government admitted thatoil was a big motivation. Hmm (still looking for source to link to..).
In Mexico the Zapatista Army of National Liberation are fighting for a reform in the way that their government works to make it more of a participatory democracy than a representative one. I.E the decisions come from the bottom-up and the electorate have more of a say. Sound a bit like tagging and folksonomy? I think so.
There are some flaws in the metaphor, but meh.
